5 min read

Ultimate Long Island Living Guide: Top Spots for Everyone's Lifestyle

Dreaming of a spot with sandy beaches, cozy neighborhoods, and endless bagels? Long Island's got you covered. It's not just about the stunning coastline; this place is a melting pot of cultures, cuisines, and communities. Whether you're a city escapee, a nature lover, or somewhere in between, there's a perfect corner here for you.

Tobi Miles
April 5, 2024
Ultimate Long Island Living Guide: Top Spots for Everyone's Lifestyle

Choosing where to plant roots in Long Island can feel like picking your favorite ice cream flavor—tough, right? But don't worry, we've scooped up the best places that offer not just a great lifestyle but also a sense of belonging. From bustling towns with hip vibes to tranquil villages that whisper "home," you're about to discover your next dream spot.

Key Takeaways

  • Diverse Neighbourhoods for Every Lifestyle: Long Island appeals to a wide range of people, from young adults looking for a vibrant nightlife in Huntington and Long Beach, to families seeking top-notch schools in Garden City and Rockville Centre, and retirees desiring quiet, scenic areas like Port Washington and Southold.
  • Consider Your Weather Preference and Crowd Tolerance: When deciding on where to live, consider the weather conditions (north shore towns receive more snow, while south shore towns experience milder winters) and crowd levels (Oyster Bay and Smithtown offer more space and tranquility).
  • Festival and Activity Rich Communities: For those who love staying active and engaged, Patchogue and Riverhead offer numerous festivals, vibrant main streets, and activities like riverfront dining and aquarium visits.
  • Cost of Living Variance Across Long Island: While Long Island is known for its higher cost of living, towns like Levittown and Massapequa provide more affordable housing options without compromising on community feel or access to amenities.
  • Nature Lover’s Paradise with Diverse Outdoor Opportunities: Long Island caters to nature enthusiasts with its diverse landscape, offering everything from beaches in Montauk, parks and hiking trails in Huntington and Oyster Bay, to vineyards and farms in the North Fork.
  • Accessibility to Urban Conveniences While Maintaining a Quiet Retreat: Ideal for city escapees, locations like Southold, Greenport, and Sag Harbor provide a serene environment without straying too far from urban amenities, perfect for young adults, families, and retirees alike.

Overview of Long Island

So, you're diving deeper into what makes Long Island the go-to spot for so many folks, huh? Let's break it down by what you might be looking for, whether it's peace and quiet, a buzzy social scene, or just the best bang for your buck.

For Young Adults

If you're fresh out of college or carving out your career path, you'll probably love places like:

  • Huntington: It's lively, with tons of bars, restaurants, and live music venues. Plus, the job market's not too shabby either.
  • Long Beach: Perfect if you can't get enough of the surf and sand. It's got a young vibe, and you’re never too far from a good time.

For Families

Looking for somewhere to settle down and maybe build a sandcastle or two? Check out:

  • Garden City: It's got great schools, gorgeous parks, and you're never too far from the city.
  • Rockville Centre: Community vibes are strong here, with lots of family-friendly activities and safe neighborhoods.

For Retirees

Craving that laid-back life or maybe picking up a new hobby? These spots are gold:

  • Port Washington: Quiet, scenic, and with plenty of spots to enjoy the waterfront.
  • Southold: It's more rural, with wineries and farms, perfect for a peaceful retreat.

Considering the Weather

If you hate shoveling snow:

  • Avoid the north shore - it tends to get more snow.
  • South Shore towns have milder winters but get ready for brisk winds.

Avoiding Crowds

  • Oyster Bay: Offers plenty of space and less of the hustle and bustle.
  • Smithtown: Larger homes and lots mean more breathing room from your neighbors.

For Festival and Activity Lovers

  • Patchogue: Festivals almost every month and a vibrant main street.
  • Riverhead: From aquarium visits to riverfront dining, it's never dull.

Keeping Costs in Check

Long Island ain't cheap, but some places offer more bang for your buck:

  • Levittown: Historically more affordable with a strong sense of community.
  • Massapequa: Offers a range of housing options, from apartments to waterfront homes.
  • North Fork: Wine

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Place to Live

Deciding on the best place to live in Long Island can feel like a hefty task, right? But don't worry, we've got you covered. When scouting for the perfect spot, there are several factors you'll want to keep in mind. Let's dive in.

For Retirees

  • Quiet Neighborhoods: Places like Garden City and Rockville Centre offer that serene environment you're probably looking for. These towns are not just about the peace; they've got some pretty cool spots to catch up with peers or enjoy a solo evening out.
  • Accessibility: Ensure the areas have easy access to healthcare. Towns like Massapequa are known for their excellent healthcare facilities.
  • Community Activities: Check if there are clubs or community centers catering to your interests. Southold, for example, boasts vibrant community gatherings.

For Young Adults

  • Vibrant Nightlife: If you're all about that social life, Patchogue and Long Beach are buzzing with bars, clubs, and beachfront parties.
  • Job Opportunities: Towns closer to NYC, like Huntington, may offer more in terms of career growth.
  • Affordability: Let's be real, finding a place that doesn't break the bank is crucial. Levittown offers a blend of affordability and a friendly environment.

For Families

  • School Districts: One word - Smithtown. Rated high for its quality education, it's a no-brainer for families.
  • Parks and Recreation: Look for towns with plenty of green spaces and family-friendly activities. Oyster Bay wins big here.
  • Safety: High on any family's list, Garden City is known for its low crime rates and community feel.

Considering Weather and Crowds

  • Best Weather: If you're after sunnier days, southern towns like Massapequa often enjoy better weather compared to their northern counterparts.
  • Avoiding Crowds: The North Fork is your go-to. It's less crowded than the Hamptons but doesn't skimp on the charm or vineyards.

Cost of Living

It's no secret that living in Long Island can be pricey. But there are areas where your dollar stretches further.

  • Riverhead and **Levitt

Best Places for City Escapees

If you're tired of the fast-paced city life and looking for a peaceful retreat without straying too far from the conveniences of urban living, Long Island offers a plethora of options that cater to various needs and preferences. Here's your ultimate guide to finding the perfect spot for city escapees on Long Island.

For Retirees

  • Southold: It's a quieter spot with a strong sense of community. Plus, the local wineries are a treat.
  • Greenport: Offers a picturesque waterfront and is great for those who still enjoy a bit of exploration.

For Young Adults

  • Huntington: It's buzzing with job opportunities, arts, and culture. The nightlife's not bad either.
  • Sag Harbor: Perfect if you're into the artsy scene and prefer a mix of beach life with a touch of history.

For Families

  • Port Jefferson: With its top-notch schools and family-friendly activities, it's a win-win.
  • Sea Cliff: Packed with parks and recreational activities. Plus, the community vibe is strong and welcoming.

Best Weather

  • Massapequa: Enjoy more sunny days here. It's ideal for beach lovers and outdoor enthusiasts.

Avoiding Crowds

  • The North Fork: Less crowded than the Hamptons but equally beautiful with its wineries and farmstands.

Festivals and Activities

  • Riverhead: Home to the famous aquarium and regularly hosts festivals. There's always something happening.

Considering Cost of Living

  • Levittown: It offers a more affordable lifestyle without compromising on the quality of living for those watching their budget.

Things to Do

  • Hit the beaches in Montauk for surfing and sunbathing.
  • Explore the rich history and art in Roslyn Village.
  • Oyster Bay: Known for its serene environment and friendly locals. It's a place where you can truly unwind and find joy.

Best Places for Nature Lovers

If you're all about that green space and love to wake up to the chirping of birds rather than the hustle and bustle of city life, Long Island's got some spots that'll make your heart sing. Let's dive into the best places for nature lovers to call home.


First up, consider Huntington if you’re big on variety. This place isn’t just about stunning views; it's a treasure chest of parks and beaches. You can spend your weekends exploring Caumsett State Park or enjoying the sun at Crab Meadow Beach. It’s perfect for families looking for educational outdoor activities, young adults seeking a picturesque jogging route, or retirees eager to connect with nature.

Oyster Bay

Got a thing for hiking or biking? Oyster Bay is your go-to. With places like Planting Fields Arboretum and Shu Swamp Nature Preserve, it's a haven for those who love to explore on foot or wheels. It's also great if you're looking to avoid crowds, offering peaceful paths that feel like they're your own secret garden.


Montauk isn't just for beach bums. Sure, the surf's great, but it's also a nature lover's dream. Camp under the stars at Hither Hills State Park or explore the walking trails at Camp Hero State Park. It’s a bit pricier, but for those who value those breathtaking ocean views and don’t mind spending a bit more, it’s worth every penny.

North Fork

If your idea of nature involves vineyards and farms as far as the eye can see, head to the North Fork. It’s less crowded than its southern counterpart, making it ideal for anyone who prefers a quieter, more laid-back vibe. Visit the Lavender by the Bay farm for a unique experience or enjoy the local wine tours. It’s a hit for retirees and families wanting a serene yet engaging environment.

Shelter Island

Nestled between the North and South Forks, Shelter Island is the epitome of tranquility. It’s accessible only by ferry, which helps keep it less crowded. Mashomack Preserve covers a third of the island, offering miles of trails through tidal creeks, mature woodlands, and marshes. It’s a paradise for bird watchers and anyone looking to get away from it all.


So there you have it! Whether you're a nature enthusiast, a beach lover, or someone who appreciates the quiet countryside, Long Island has something special for you. From Huntington's vibrant parks to Montauk's adventurous trails and the North Fork's charming vineyards, each place offers its unique flavor of tranquility and outdoor fun. And if it's peace you're after, Shelter Island's secluded beauty is hard to beat. It's time to explore these gems and find your perfect spot in the beautiful tapestry of Long Island. Happy house hunting!

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Huntington attractive to nature lovers?

Huntington stands out for its diverse parks and beaches, offering ample opportunities for engaging in a variety of outdoor activities that cater to nature enthusiasts.

Why is Oyster Bay ideal for hiking and biking?

Oyster Bay is renowned for its serene hiking and biking paths, which provide a picturesque and tranquil setting for enthusiasts to explore and enjoy the area's natural beauty.

What outdoor activities can you do in Montauk?

Besides its famous beaches, Montauk is a prime location for camping and enjoying scenic walking trails, allowing visitors to immerse themselves in its unique natural landscape.

Why is the North Fork appealing to individuals who love a quieter environment?

The North Fork is cherished for its vineyards and farms, set in a more secluded and peaceful environment, making it a perfect retreat for those seeking a break from the hustle and bustle.

What makes Shelter Island a haven for bird watchers?

Shelter Island's extensive natural trails and its peaceful, ferry-accessible location provide a unique sanctuary for bird watchers and individuals looking for a tranquil escape amidst nature.

Tobi Miles
Article updated:
April 5, 2024
A nomadic wordsmith savoring the world's flavors and penning stories that turn every journey into an epic.
Find me on Twitter

Win a $500 Flight!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
*Terms apply. To participate, enter your email to sign up for the newsletter . You must be 18+ and be a resident of the US. No purchase necessary. Begins January 1st  and ends February 28th, 2024. Winner announced on March 31st. For full rules and regulations, visit our Terms & Conditions page. Data  processed according to our Privacy Policy.
Enter Sweepstakes

You may also like...


Win a $500 Flight!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
*Terms apply. To participate, enter your email to sign up for the newsletter . You must be 18+ and be a resident of the US. No purchase necessary. Begins January 1st  and ends February 28th, 2024. Winner announced on March 31st. For full rules and regulations, visit our Terms & Conditions page. Data  processed according to our Privacy Policy.
Enter Sweepstakes